Preacher Cookies

  • 2 cups sugar
  • 1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa
  • 1/2 cup milk
  • 1/2 cup margarine (1 stick) or 1/2 cup solid vegetable shortening
  • Dash salt
  • 1/4 cup peanut butter
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 2 cups rolled oats

First take out a nice 2-quart saucepan. In it combine the sugar, cocoa, milk and margarine. Cook and stir the mixture over medium heat until the margarine melts, and the sugar dissolves. Bring the pot to a boil, and reduce the heat slightly. Simmer the mixture for several minutes, until the chocolate forms a soft ball when dropped into a bowl of cold water. This is about 234° on a candy thermometer. Remove the pan from the heat when it reaches the soft ball stage. Add the salt, peanut butter and vanilla. Stir until the peanut butter is dissolved. Finally stir in the oatmeal. The mixture may seem a little runny, but will thicken up as it cools. Drop the mixture from a tablespoon onto a sheet of waxed paper. It should form medium sized cookies. Depending on the size of the cookie, you may end up with as few as 15 or as many as 24.

This is my favorite recipe in the whole wide world. It got it’s name because it could be prepared quickly when a housewife looked out her window and saw the preacher riding up the mountain on his horse. By the time the preacher arrived, the cookies were cooling. I remember family members making them for me as a kid, and I still have people calling me just to request this recipe over the phone. This one recipe could make the reputation of a good cook.

The Hillbilly Housewife Recommends

homemade-mixes-kindleHomemade Mixes – Make It Yourself and Save

Making your own mix from scratch rather than buying it in the store not only saves you money but also saves you from all the additives and preservatives that are put in the foods we buy.

Find out how easy it is to make your own seasonings, baking mixes, beverage mixes and more in this HBHW Kindle Cookbook.

 The recipes include:

Apple Pie Spice Mix
Basic Muffin Mix
Brownie Mix
Caribbean Jerk Seasoning
Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix
Corn Bread Mix
Cream of Soup Mix
Fajita Seasoning
Fish Fry Coating Mix
Fruited Oatmeal Mix
Homemade Taco Seasoning Mix
Homemade Vanilla Chai Tea Mix

Articles From The Hillbilly Housewife

Scrambled Egg and Tomato

Standing Up and Scotch Eggs – Whole 30 Day 3

I was busy working on today’s newsletter while I was drinking my coffee and kept breakfast simple. I had a beautiful large tomato ready from the garden and just fixed some scrambled eggs cooked in a little ghee to go with it. Sometimes simple meals are my favorites and it was hard to beat the […]

Chicken Salad with Tomatoes

Making Ghee and Egg Cups – Whole 30 Day 2

Day Two on Whole 30 went pretty smooth. I think it helps that I’ve been pretty busy all week so far. I’m still struggling with the whole “eating breakfast as soon as you get up” thing. I’m not ready for food until after I had my coffee and had time to think about what I […]

Salt Water Cleanse Recipe

Saltwater Cleanse and Noodles – Whole 30 Day 1 Recap

Tracy and I decided over the weekend to give the Whole 30 program a try. I talked more about it here, but basically we’re eating clean and cutting out sugar, grains, dairy and legumes for the next 30 days and see how we feel. I started playing around over the weekend eating most of my […]


Starting Whole 30 – Wanna Join Us?

I had such high hopes  in January that this would be the year when I finally get healthy and lose a bunch of weight. Fast forward a few short weeks and I was back on my old unhealthy eating schedule. I was too busy, eating healthy was too expensive, the list of excuses could go […]

Making Ice Cream Without An Ice Cream Maker

How To Make Ice Cream Without An Ice Cream Maker

If you don’t have an ice cream maker, don’t fret.  You can make ice cream at home without the aid of either a hand-cranked machine or an electric ice cream maker. How?  All you need is a freezer, and a little muscle. Here’s how to do it. This will work with any ice cream recipe. […]


  1. Rebecca says

    I just finished this recipe, and it’s REALLY good..It made 22 cookies, and they are just cooling. Thanks so much for the recipe!!

    • kenneth says

      great recipe, had to tweek it though, wife is diabetic 2 cups splenda + 1/2 cup sugar cuts the carbs way down but still taste very good

  2. rebecca says

    My 3 sons loved this when I made it. Its really good to eat for breakfast,its just a chocolate flavored oatmeal treat. on the go and no time for breakfast,works for us!

  3. Mae says

    Hate to tell you what we call these cookies. Cow Patties! LOL A big favorite in my family. I love them when they are still warm.

  4. Laura says

    My Mom made something very close to this called “Top of the Stove Cookies” and we loved them (I still love them).

  5. Irene Fisher says

    I have heard these called “Preacher Cookies”. Many years ago the pastor would visit his congregational members weekly. When he came to call, it was customary to have coffee or tea and a refreshment such as cake, cookies, etc. They got this name because you were supposed to be able to make them as you saw the preacher coming up the sidewalk. They would be ready by the time he got to the door. :)

  6. GrannieAnnie says

    I am 60 yrs old, made these since I was a teenager but never heard them called Preacher Cookie. We always called them No-bakes, but whatever the you call them they are a easy, great cookie no matter how old you are.

  7. CarolinaGirl says

    I have always loved these cookies! Growing up, my family always called them Oatmeal Drop Cookies. When my husband and I first started dating, I discovered that his family called them “Preacher Cookies”. No matter what they are called, they are always delicious! And, I like to think to myself that they are healthier than other cookies because of the oatmeal! I’ll have to try to cut the sugar with Splenda and maybe I’ll feel even less guilty!

  8. Elaine says

    I come from Southwest Virginia and we always called them Preacher Cookies. My kids always have loved them. When my son was in the Navy he called me from Japan once just to get the recipe!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *