Baked Custard Recipe

  • 2-1/2 cups tap water
  • 1 cup instant nonfat dry milk
  • 3 medium eggs
  • 1/3 cup sugar
  • 1/4 teaspoon cinnamon or nutmeg
  • 1/2 teaspoon vanilla
  • 2 tablespoons melted margarine

This is a delicious old-fashioned dessert that you don’t see very often any more.  That’s a shame too because baked custard is one of those yummy comfort foods that is inexpensive, easy and nutritious.

Start off with your favorite mixing bowl.  Pour the water into it and add the dry milk.  Stir until the milk is dissolved.  Add the eggs.  Whisk or beat well.  Add the sugar, cinnamon, vanilla and melted margarine.  Mix again, for about 2 minutes by hand, or until the sugar is dissolved, the eggs are well incorporated and the margarine isn’t trying to rise to the top.

Oil a 1-1/2 to 2 quart sized casserole dish.  Pour the custard into the casserole.  Now you have to find another pan that is bigger than your casserole so you can make a “water bath” for your custard.  I usually use a standard 9 by 13-inch baking pan.  Place the casserole inside the pan.  Now add tap water to the outer pan, a little at a time, until it is half-way up the side of the casserole. Place the whole contraption into the oven.  Set the temperature for 350F.  Bake for approximately 45 minutes.  When you insert a knife into the baked custard it should come out clean.  If your casserole is deep it make take longer than 45 minutes.  If your casserole is shallow it may take less time.

When the custard is done remove it from the oven and the hot water bath.  Allow it to cool for 1 or 2 hours.  It may now be chilled until serving time, or served warm.  Warm custard is good, but cold custard is better.  If desired you may top your  custard with a small spoonful of molasses or a sprinkle of cinnamon.  This baked custard recipe makes 4 hearty servings, or 6 healthy servings.

The Hillbilly Housewife Recommends – Dining On A Dime

The Dining On A Dime Cookbook is packed with over 1,200 money saving recipes and tips, kids tips and snack ideas, gift baskets, menus, food storage directions, Cleaning Cents and Pretty for Pennies. The recipes are easy to cook with ingredients that you probably already have in your pantry. To make shopping easy and economical, it also includes a pantry list and a shopping list.

Order your copy today at

The Hillbilly Housewife Recommends

homemade-mixes-kindleHomemade Mixes – Make It Yourself and Save

Making your own mix from scratch rather than buying it in the store not only saves you money but also saves you from all the additives and preservatives that are put in the foods we buy.

Find out how easy it is to make your own seasonings, baking mixes, beverage mixes and more in this HBHW Kindle Cookbook.

 The recipes include:

Apple Pie Spice Mix
Basic Muffin Mix
Brownie Mix
Caribbean Jerk Seasoning
Chocolate Chip Cookie Mix
Corn Bread Mix
Cream of Soup Mix
Fajita Seasoning
Fish Fry Coating Mix
Fruited Oatmeal Mix
Homemade Taco Seasoning Mix
Homemade Vanilla Chai Tea Mix

Articles From The Hillbilly Housewife

Scrambled Egg and Tomato

Standing Up and Scotch Eggs – Whole 30 Day 3

I was busy working on today’s newsletter while I was drinking my coffee and kept breakfast simple. I had a beautiful large tomato ready from the garden and just fixed some scrambled eggs cooked in a little ghee to go with it. Sometimes simple meals are my favorites and it was hard to beat the […]

Chicken Salad with Tomatoes

Making Ghee and Egg Cups – Whole 30 Day 2

Day Two on Whole 30 went pretty smooth. I think it helps that I’ve been pretty busy all week so far. I’m still struggling with the whole “eating breakfast as soon as you get up” thing. I’m not ready for food until after I had my coffee and had time to think about what I […]

Salt Water Cleanse Recipe

Saltwater Cleanse and Noodles – Whole 30 Day 1 Recap

Tracy and I decided over the weekend to give the Whole 30 program a try. I talked more about it here, but basically we’re eating clean and cutting out sugar, grains, dairy and legumes for the next 30 days and see how we feel. I started playing around over the weekend eating most of my […]


Starting Whole 30 – Wanna Join Us?

I had such high hopes  in January that this would be the year when I finally get healthy and lose a bunch of weight. Fast forward a few short weeks and I was back on my old unhealthy eating schedule. I was too busy, eating healthy was too expensive, the list of excuses could go […]

Making Ice Cream Without An Ice Cream Maker

How To Make Ice Cream Without An Ice Cream Maker

If you don’t have an ice cream maker, don’t fret.  You can make ice cream at home without the aid of either a hand-cranked machine or an electric ice cream maker. How?  All you need is a freezer, and a little muscle. Here’s how to do it. This will work with any ice cream recipe. […]


  1. Katie says

    Help! I can’t get my custard to set up. It’s always watery or curdled. I’ve used cold water bath, hot water bath, cooking hotter, cooking longer, using different sized pans, it never sets up.
    What am I doing wrong?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *